New York City
Quick delivery apps
-
Instacart
city-wide Stock seen on the page
Brands on the page: Oatly, Planet Oat, Califia Farms, Chobani, Silk, Elmhurst
Opened the Oat Milk category page, which loads with its own title and names Oatly, Planet Oat, Califia, Chobani, Silk and Elmhurst products. Which of these reach a given New York address depends on the store selected, which is address-gated.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
Supermarkets
-
Morton Williams Supermarket
city-wide Stock not confirmed
Opened the chain's Milk collection page, which loads with the title 'Milk Same-Day Delivery | Morton Williams Supermarket', and mortonwilliams.com, whose title names Manhattan. The product grid is rendered by JavaScript, so no individual plant milk could be read.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
-
Whole Foods Market
city-wide Stock not confirmed
Opened wholefoodsmarket.com and its Stores page, both of which load with real Whole Foods Market titles. The store finder itself runs in JavaScript, so no individual New York branch page and no plant-milk listing could be read from the HTML served. A guessed /stores/new-york path returned a 'Page Not Found' title and was discarded.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
-
Trader Joe's
city-wide Stock not confirmed
Opened the chain's own location directory for New York, NY, which loads with the title 'Trader Joe's Locations in New York, NY' and lists its Manhattan branches. Trader Joe's publishes no online product catalogue, so stock of plant milk at any branch could not be checked.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
-
Target
Union Square, Manhattan Stock not confirmed
Opened the Manhattan Union Square store page on target.com, which loads with the title 'Target Manhattan Union Square Store, New York, NY' and describes groceries among the departments. The grocery assortment for that branch is loaded by JavaScript and could not be read.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
Health food and vegan shops
-
Westerly Natural Market
Midtown, Manhattan Stock not confirmed
Opened westerlynaturalmarket.com, which gives the address 911 8th Avenue, Corner of W. 54th St NY NY 10019, and its Mercato-hosted shop, whose page data gives the same New York, NY address and says the market is available for online ordering and local delivery. The product catalogue is loaded by JavaScript, so no plant milk was visible on the page served.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
-
Union Market
Brooklyn Stock not confirmed
Opened the Locations page on unionmarket.com, which gives Crown Heights, Brooklyn and Prospect Heights, Brooklyn branches with NY 11216 and NY 11238 addresses, and the Departments page, which lists a Cheese & Dairy department. The online shop at shop.unionmarket.com returned a Cloudflare challenge instead of a catalogue.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
Direct from the brand
-
Nuthatch
Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens Stock seen on the page
Brands on the page: Nuthatch
Opened the Almond Collection on the brand's own Shopify store, which lists 14 almond-based products, and the Almond product page, which prints a full ingredient list.
Ingredient list read on 2026-09-09
Filtered Water, Blanched Almonds* (*Organic)
Potato or tapioca starch: not named in the list read
-
Elmhurst 1925
nationwide Stock seen on the page
Brands on the page: Elmhurst 1925
Opened the Oat Products collection on the brand's own site, which links Milked Oats, Unsweetened Milked Oats, Milked Oats Chocolate and Barista Oats product pages. The Unsweetened Oat Milk page describes three ingredients but does not print the list itself.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
-
Oatly
city-wide Stock not confirmed
Brands on the page: Oatly
Opened oatly.com and the brand's Oatfinder tool, both of which load. Oatfinder is a Next.js application that resolves stockists only after a location is entered, so no specific New York stockist could be read from the page served.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
-
Califia Farms
nationwide Stock not confirmed
Brands on the page: Califia Farms
Opened the brand's own store locator page on califiafarms.com, which loads. The locator results are fetched by JavaScript, so no New York stockist appeared in the HTML served.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
Local shops and cafes
-
Nuthatch
Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens Stock seen on the page
Brands on the page: Nuthatch
Opened nuthatchlocal.com, whose home page states 'We offer local delivery in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens.' The Fresh Plant-Based Milks collection returns 17 products including Oat, Almond, Cashew, Hemp and Pumpkin Seed milks.
Ingredient list read on 2026-09-09
Filtered Water, New York State Oats* (*Organic)
Potato or tapioca starch: not named in the list read
-
Orchard Grocer
Lower East Side, Manhattan Stock not confirmed
Opened orchardgrocer.com, which loads with the title 'Best Vegan Food in Lower East Side, New York City | Orchard Grocer' for the all-vegan shop at 78 Orchard St. Its ordering menu is served by a Chowly app in JavaScript, so no plant-milk carton could be seen on a page that was opened.
Potato or tapioca starch: no list was read, so not known
Other cities
FreshDirect could not be included: every request to freshdirect.com from curl returned no response at all, and the WebFetch fallback timed out, so no FreshDirect page could be opened. Good Eggs was rejected because its home page loaded but named no New York delivery area. Orchard Grocer's shop is a Chowly-hosted ordering site whose menu is loaded by JavaScript, so no plant milk could be seen on a page that was opened; it is recorded as unconfirmed. Most supermarket and quick-commerce pages render their product grids in JavaScript, so brand lists and ingredient panels were usually not readable in the HTML actually served.